Specifying and replacing Siemens SITRANS FM electromagnetic flowmeters and compact pressure transmitters: MAG 3100 process sensors against MAG 5100 W water sensors and where each belongs, the MAG 5000/6000 transmitter pairing and remote against compact mounting, liner and electrode selection by medium, the installation rules (straight runs, grounding, full pipe) that decide accuracy more than the datasheet does, the MAGFLO heritage that lets decades-old nameplates cross directly to current 7ME codes, and the SITRANS P200-class compact pressure transmitters that answer most 4-20 mA pressure RFQs in one line.
| Criterion | MAG 5100 W | MAG 3100 |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | Water, wastewater, irrigation, district utilities | Process industry, marine systems, chemistry, slurries |
| Liners | EPDM / ebonite-class rubber; drinking-water approvals available | Rubber classes for water/abrasion, PTFE class for chemistry and temperature |
| Pressure/temperature envelope | Utility class (PN10/16 typical) | Up to PN40 class and higher temperatures — e.g. the DN32 PN40 unit |
| Size span | Utility DN range, economical at volume | Wide DN span small to very large |
| Typical RFQ | "DN100 water meter, drinking water approval, compact" | "DN100 PN40, EPDM liner, seawater cooling, remote transmitter" — i.e. the 7ME6310 class |
Sizing is by velocity, not by pipe: magmeters read best in roughly the 1–3 m/s band, so a chronically oversized line wants a sensor one or two DN below pipe size with conical transitions — the single most common correction we make to flowmeter RFQs. Conductivity floor: ordinary waters pass easily; demineralised/ultra-pure water sits at or below the limit — check before specifying, or choose a different principle.
| Choice | Take it when | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| MAG 5000 | Standard accuracy class covers the duty (utility totalising, balance metering) | The economical transmitter |
| MAG 6000 | Tighter accuracy class, more I/O/comms options wanted | The spec-sheet default in industry; our stocked units pair it — e.g. MAG 5100 W DN50 + MAG 6000 CT |
| Compact mount | Accessible, benign location | One article, no sensor cable questions |
| Remote mount | Hot, flooded, vibrating or buried sensors; display wanted at eye level | Sensor cable type/length per the manual — the hidden failure point; order the cable with the meter |
| Replacement economics | Transmitters die (lightning, moisture, age) far more often than sensors: a MAG 6000 cartridge swap revives a 20-year-old sensor in minutes — quote the transmitter alone before condemning the line item | |
| Rule | The working number | Why RFQs happen when it is ignored |
|---|---|---|
| Full pipe, always | Mount in a rising line or flooded section; never the high point | Air at the electrodes reads as flow noise and drift — the #1 "faulty meter" that is not |
| Straight runs | A few DN upstream, a couple downstream (the manual's figures govern per disturbance) | Elbows and half-open valves upstream skew the profile the meter integrates |
| Grounding | Grounding rings or built-in grounding electrodes on lined/plastic/cathodically-protected pipe; straps on bare metal | Stray potentials ride the signal — wandering zero, jumpy totals; rings belong on the order for any lined line |
| Electrode axis | Horizontal lines: electrodes horizontal (3 and 9 o'clock) | Sediment and bubbles cross vertical electrodes |
| Zero and verification | Zero at commissioning on a full, standing line; periodic verification per QA | Fiscal/balance duties want the verification record — ask for it with the meter |
On ships these rules meet reality in ballast and cooling systems: the meter goes where the yard left room, not where the manual dreams — which makes grounding rings, conical reducers and remote transmitters the standard accessories on marine magmeter orders, and we quote them proactively rather than watching the meter come back "faulty" in six months.
Reordering a flow sensor: the nameplate's 7ME code (7ME6520 = MAG 5100 W class, 7ME6310 = MAG 3100 class) plus DN/PN and liner tells the whole story; absent a readable plate, DN + PN + liner colour/material + transmitter type identifies it. MAGFLO-era plates (Danfoss flow heritage: MAGFLO MAG 1100/3100/5100, transmitter MAG 5000/6000) cross directly into the current SITRANS FM programme — same family logic, flange-for-flange in most sizes; send the plate photo and the current code comes back. The pressure side: the SITRANS P200 class (7MF1565) and its gauge/absolute siblings (7MF1567 — 3CA00, 3DG00 variants) are compact ceramic-cell 4-20 mA transmitters covering the 0-x bar ranges that make up most pressure RFQs; selection = range, process connection (G1/4 class), output, and accuracy class — with the Danfoss MBS guide as the cross-brand twin and the switch-vs-transmitter guide for the architecture question. Signal integration (4-20 mA vs IO-Link vs HART) is covered in the signals guide; calibration practice in the calibrator guide.
How buying works at cballast. We quote sensors, transmitters, grounding rings, cables and verification accessories as one configured line, cross MAGFLO-era plates to current codes, and flag installation findings honestly before replacing healthy hardware. Accounts are vetted at onboarding; first order prepaid; established accounts on credit terms with repeat discounts; public bodies and utilities invoiced against purchase order from the first order. RFQs to sales@cballast.com.
Standards and sources referenced: Siemens SITRANS FM documentation (MAG 3100/5100 W sensors, MAG 5000/6000 transmitters — installation, grounding, liner/electrode selection), SITRANS P compact transmitter data; the Danfoss-heritage MAGFLO programme mapping; general magmeter practice per ISO 6817-class guidance.
Questions on a sizing, a liner choice or an old plate: write to sales@cballast.com. We answer whether or not you buy from us.